High Contrast:
Get Started
Picture of Scott Phegley
Scott Phegley | NMLS: 610874

Let me help you get pre-approved today!

I am a Senior Mortgage Loan Officer with Ruoff Mortgage, serving both Indiana and Illinois. I bring over 24 years of real estate and mortgage lending experience and expertise. Service is always the foundation of my business and I believe in providing the best home-buying experience possible and I will continuously strive to exceed your expectations. Good communication is the key to excellent customer service and a top priority for me.

Whether you are buying your first home, refinancing your current home, looking to build or wanting to move up, we will work together to find the right product and solution to all of your financial needs. Call me today and let's get started.

Get Started

President's Club Member

President's club seal 2022
President's club seal 2023
President's club seal 2024
President's club seal 2025

What is your goal?

Buy a Home

From finding your perfect home to moving in, we've got you covered.

Refinance

Need a lower monthly payment, or want to get cash out? Learn more about your options.

Sell My Home

Get your house on the market, and look for your next home!

Hear from people like you

  • Review 1

    Source of Rating Icon

    Very good communication, nice and honest.

    Randa L C.

    Lawrenceville, IL, July 10th, 2026 11:04 AM

  • Review 2

    Source of Rating Icon

    Friendly staff vary knowledgeable and organized

    Nicholas K P.

    Sullivan, IN, July 6th, 2026 11:08 AM

  • Review 3

    Source of Rating Icon

    I love the fact that there was no AI lol, this team was available whenever needed. Scott is amazing, always had the answers, never left us in the dark about anything. I would give his name to anyone who was interested about a loan. I already have done this once, given his name to a CO-worker. I feel that I was blessed with Scott. He is so knowledgeable, never put on hold, worked over time on getting things put together and faster than I expected. We just love how quick and accurate Scott took care of us. Friendly, awesome attitude, makes you feel like family. He's a keeper. !!!

    Laura Lee P.

    Sullivan, IN, July 4th, 2026 08:44 AM

  • Review 4

    Source of Rating Icon

    Scott was amazing! Very knowledgeable and always there when I had questions! Prompt communication and excellent understanding of life situations and the whole loan process was a major part of what makes Scott so amazing! Would definitely recommend him to anyone and everyone I know! Thank you Scott for being there for us and helping us through the process with a smile on your face! You can hear the smile in his voice it's so refreshing working with someone like Scott!!

    Zane G.

    Sullivan, IN, June 27th, 2026 03:10 PM

  • Review 5

    Source of Rating Icon

    Scott Phegley was great to work with he answered all of our questions and gave us some good advice along the way. We very grateful for Scott and the rest of the Ruoff folks for helping us get the house we wanted.

    Jacob Seth H.

    Palestine, IL, June 22nd, 2026 06:01 PM

  • Review 6

    Source of Rating Icon

    I love the easy step-by-step process made things go smoothly and fast. I will be recommending Scott to anyone looking to buy a new home. He was fantastic to work with. He made it a breeze.

    Lori J P.

    Farmersburg, IN, June 22nd, 2026 11:07 AM

  • Review 7

    Source of Rating Icon

    Scott and his team were so patient and kind! I was given all the tools and information I needed to make this journey smooth. I would recommend Scott and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home if you want a seamless , calm, and enjoyable process!

    Kaitlyn N P.

    Bicknell, IN, June 22nd, 2026 11:04 AM

  • Review 8

    Source of Rating Icon

    You made it easy for us to go through the application process and get our loan

    Cody Alan D.

    Jasonville, IN, June 20th, 2026 08:10 AM

  • Review 9

    Source of Rating Icon

    Scott was amazing to work with he answered any and all questions I had almost immediately everytime I reached out to him! I would recommend Scott to anyone that is buying a home it was honestly a breeze working with him He was very knowledgeable and gave lots of information to every question! he's a great guy!

    Briana S.

    Annapolis, IL, June 13th, 2026 07:24 PM

  • Review 10

    Source of Rating Icon

    The communication and the helpfulness answering questions for first time homebuyers was great and super insightful

    John Paul S.

    Annapolis, IL, June 13th, 2026 11:07 AM

  • Review 11

    Source of Rating Icon

    Everything went very fast!

    Zachary Ellis D.

    Robinson, IL, June 7th, 2026 11:16 AM

  • Review 12

    Source of Rating Icon

    Even though the communication process was mostly online, I was still highly satisfied with how quickly Scott's team responded to us. They were able to explain the loan process in great detail in ways us first time home buyers were able to understand. Scott's team was very personable and supportive while still being professional, which we highly appreciate. We will be reccomending Ruoff to our friends and families.

    Kyndal R.

    Oblong, IL, May 19th, 2026 03:47 PM

  • Review 13

    Source of Rating Icon

    You guys actually did everything you said you were going to do and made everything happen for us! y'all made a dream a reality.

    Lara Q.

    Carlisle, IN, May 17th, 2026 03:42 PM

See More

Why should you choose Ruoff?

69

Branches throughout
the US.

98.5%

Customer Satisfaction Score.*

15

Days or less average
clear-to-close.**

42

Years of helping
homeowners like you.

7

Milestones updating you throughout the process.

10

Minutes at the closing
table on average.

*Based on 2025 independent third party customer satisfaction survey data. This is not an offer for extension of credit or a commitment to lend. All loans must satisfy company underwriting guidelines. Information and interest rate are subject to change at any time and without notice. Equal Housing Lender. NMLS #141868. Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. is an Indiana corporation. For complete licensing information visit: http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org/EntityDetails.aspx/COMPANY/141868.

** The average Clear to Close time is dependent on loan type, proper documentation, and other qualifying factors. Loan decision is subject to satisfactory appraisal, title review, and no change to financial condition. This is not an offer for extension of credit or a commitment to lend. Some restrictions may apply. Ruoff Mortgage NMLS #141868. Equal Housing Lender. Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. d/b/a Ruoff Mortgage is an Indiana corporation. For complete licensing information visit: http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org/EntityDetails.aspx/COMPANY/141868.

Calculate what's best for you

Use our calculator below to find an estimated monthly mortgage payment that works for you. Please remember the dollar amounts displayed are not guaranteed, and what you actually pay may be different. These estimates are for educational purposes only.

Stay connected.

I would love to hear from you!

Call me at 812.239.5566 or message me below!

Download our !